the padded cell

Learning with Genies

What skills do we keep when answers are cheap? When genies (or calculators, or GPS, or AI) can do things for us, how do we decide what’s worth learning deeply vs. what we’re happy to delegate? How do we maintain judgment and taste when we can outsource execution? And how do we avoid becoming the humans in Wall-E, and is that even a legit concern?

3 posts in this series

When everyone gets a genie

learning to handle expertise you didn't earn

We’ve always had to figure out who to trust for expertise, but until now, that access wasn’t universal. Used to be the bloke at the pub who ‘knew things,’ or that friend of a friend who could fix computers (me as a kid), or books if you had the patience. Rich people had their ‘real’ experts on call, though Bernie Madoff shows how well that could work out.

The internet changed things, sure. Suddenly you could reach out to actual experts, find communities, and learn from people across the world. But you still needed judgment, because you could also find a community that agreed the earth was flat, so, you know, mixed bag.

[… more]
blog • • 10 min read • #thinking-out-loud, #ai, #genie, #learning

Went looking for that old ‘kids today don’t memorize’ quote and found an old argument against writing:

[…] They will cease to exercise memory because they rely on that which is written, calling things to remembrance no longer from within themselves, but by means of external marks. […]

One thing we’re not doing as effectively today as we’ve done in the past is to learn lessons by heart. If you don’t know things with perfect recall, how can you expect to apply them?

Socrates goes on to compare a written text to a painting:

You know, Phaedrus, that is the strange thing about writing, which makes it truly correspond to painting. The painter’s products stand before us as though they were alive. But if you question them, they maintain a most majestic silence. It is the same with written words. They seem to talk to you as though they were intelligent, but if you ask them anything about what they say from a desire to be instructed they go on telling just the same thing forever.

That last bit especially, “if you ask them anything… they go on telling just the same thing forever.” This all sounds exactly like how we’re talking about genies today, and… we’re probably going to be fine.

link • • #genie, #learning

Simon Sinek on AI and the value of struggle, via Arjit:

People keep telling us life is not about the destination. Life is about the journey. But when we think about AI, we only think about the destination. And it’s remarkable ability to write the book, paint the painting, solve the problem, but we forget the importance of doing the work yourself.

And I think in our modern day and age, we have underrepresented the value of struggle. I am smarter, better at problem solving, more resourceful, not because a book exists with my ideas in it, but because I wrote it. That excruciating journey is what made me grow.

But it’s the same for love, friendships, conflict. And I think that we forget that we give up certain skills or abilities because of technology.

The struggle is the point. More people can generate a mediocre painting or write perfect English now, but they won’t understand the beauty behind either without doing the work. And it’s our prerogative to decide which struggles matter to us or if we just wanted something nice to hang in the toilet.

link • • #ai, #genie, #learning